Department Store Dispatch

Macy's Gift Cards: Where American Retail Tradition Meets Modern Commerce

DISPATCH #47 | January 2025 Edition

---

HEADLINE STORY

Macy's Gift Card Revenue Defies Department Store Decline Narrative

While headlines chronicle department store struggles, Macy's gift card program tells a different story—one of enduring relevance and strategic adaptation. The iconic retailer's gift card division generated approximately $1.4 billion in annual revenue, maintaining its position as America's largest department store gift card program.

This dispatch examines how Macy's leverages 165 years of retail heritage while confronting modern competitive pressures.

---

DISPATCH BRIEFING: Market Position

By The Numbers:

Indicator	Value	YoY Change
Annual Gift Card Sales	$1.4B	-2.3%
Active Cards	31.2M	+1.1%
Average Card Value	$44.80	+$2.40
Digital Share	38%	+7 pts
Redemption Rate	94.2%	+0.8 pts

Assessment: Overall revenue decline masks positive underlying metrics—higher card values and better redemption rates indicate strengthening consumer engagement per card issued.

---

DISPATCH ANALYSIS: The Macy's Gift Card Advantage

1. Category Breadth

Unlike specialty retailers, Macy's gift cards unlock access to:

• Women's apparel and accessories
• Men's clothing and grooming
• Children's wear
• Home goods and furniture
• Beauty and cosmetics (including Clinique, Estée Lauder)
• Fine jewelry and watches
• Mattresses and bedding

This breadth makes Macy's cards versatile gifts suitable for virtually any recipient, reducing the "wrong fit" anxiety common with single-category gift cards.

2. Price Point Flexibility

Macy's inventory spans extreme price ranges, enabling gift card recipients to find satisfying purchases regardless of balance:

Balance Distribution → Common Purchase Categories

$25 or less:    Cosmetics, small accessories, clearance items
$26-50:         Casual apparel, home décor, beauty sets
$51-100:        Premium apparel, designer accessories, small appliances
$101-200:       Designer items, bedding sets, jewelry
$200+:          Fine jewelry, furniture, high-end fashion

3. Brand Portfolio Access

A Macy's gift card provides entry to numerous brand shops-within-shops:

• INC International Concepts (exclusive)
• Tommy Hilfiger
• Calvin Klein
• Michael Kors
• Coach
• Martha Stewart Collection (home)

---

DISPATCH SPECIAL REPORT: Seasonal Dynamics

The Thanksgiving-to-Christmas Corridor

Macy's gift card sales concentrate heavily in Q4, driven by:

Thanksgiving Week: The Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade creates unique brand moment. Gift card purchases spike 340% above baseline as parade viewers associate brand with holiday tradition.

Black Friday Weekend: Door-buster shoppers purchase gift cards for those who couldn't attend. Digital card sales peak for immediate sharing with remote family members.

December Rush: Last-minute gifters default to trusted Macy's brand. E-gift card sales represent 67% of December digital transactions.

Post-Christmas: Redemption surge as recipients shop winter clearance and January white sales.

Quarterly Volume Distribution:

Q1 (Jan-Mar):  ████████████████░░░░ 28% (redemption heavy)
Q2 (Apr-Jun):  ██████████░░░░░░░░░░ 17% (wedding/graduation)
Q3 (Jul-Sep):  ██████████░░░░░░░░░░ 18% (back-to-school)
Q4 (Oct-Dec):  ████████████████████ 37% (holiday dominance)

---

DISPATCH FIELD NOTES: Consumer Profiles

Profile A: The Traditionalist (34%) Demographics: 50+, suburban, established households Behavior: Purchases physical cards for grandchildren and extended family; values in-store shopping experience; associates Macy's with quality and reliability Average Gift Card Value: $52.30 Preferred Format: Physical with gift box

Profile B: The Practical Gifter (28%) Demographics: 35-54, working professionals Behavior: Chooses Macy's for versatility when unsure of recipient preferences; values free shipping thresholds; appreciates work attire options Average Gift Card Value: $48.60 Preferred Format: Mix of physical and digital

Profile C: The Beauty Enthusiast (22%) Demographics: 25-44, predominantly female Behavior: Targets Macy's specifically for cosmetics counter access; values brand selection; redeems primarily in beauty department Average Gift Card Value: $36.40 Preferred Format: Digital for immediate gratification

Profile D: The Deal Hunter (16%) Demographics: Broad age range, value-conscious Behavior: Times redemptions to major sales events; maximizes Star Rewards multipliers; stretches gift card value through strategic shopping Average Gift Card Value: $41.20 Preferred Format: Digital (easier to combine with coupons)

---

DISPATCH INVESTIGATION: Competitive Landscape

Department Store Competitors:

Nordstrom: Premium positioning commands higher average gift card values ($68 vs. $44 for Macy's) but smaller addressable market. Nordstrom gift cards signal "treat yourself" occasions.

Kohl's: Value positioning and Kohl's Cash integration creates loyalty complexity. Gift card givers uncertain how rewards apply to recipients.

JCPenney: Struggling brand perception impacts gift card desirability. Price-conscious consumers may prefer, but gifters hesitant.

Dillard's: Regional strength in South and Southwest. Gift cards function well for local gifting but lack national recognition.

E-Commerce Competitors:

Amazon: Dominant threat for practical gifting occasions. Macy's counters with in-store experience, brand curation, and emotional purchase context.

Shopify Stores: Direct-to-consumer brands capture younger shoppers who bypass department stores entirely.

---

DISPATCH TECHNOLOGY REPORT: Digital Transformation

Mobile App Integration:

Macy's mobile app now serves as primary gift card management hub:

• Balance check with barcode scan
• Add to Apple Wallet/Google Pay
• View transaction history
• Send as gift directly from app
• Apply to online purchases seamlessly

App Usage Statistics:

• 2.8M users actively store gift cards in-app
• 47% of digital redemptions occur via mobile
• App users show 23% higher gift card utilization rates

Omnichannel Capabilities:

• Buy online, redeem in-store (and vice versa)
• Ship-to-store for gift card purchases
• Curbside pickup with gift card payment
• Same-day delivery accepting gift card funds

---

DISPATCH SPECIAL SECTION: Star Rewards Integration

How Star Rewards Amplifies Gift Card Value:

Macy's Star Rewards loyalty program creates unique gift card dynamics:

For Gift Card Recipients:

• Earn Star Rewards points on gift card redemptions
• Status tiers (Insider, Gold, Platinum) accelerate earning
• Birthday rewards stack with gift card balances
• Star Money accumulated can fund future purchases

For Gift Card Givers:

• Earn points when purchasing gift cards
• Platinum members earn 5% back on gift card purchases
• Credit card holders receive additional multipliers

Integration Statistics:

• 71% of gift card redemptions link to Star Rewards accounts
• Linked users spend 34% more per gift card
• Star Money redemption drives additional store visits

---

DISPATCH MARKET INTELLIGENCE: Gift Card Distribution

Where Macy's Gift Cards Are Sold:

Macy's Stores:           ████████████████░░░░ 42%
Macys.com:               ████████████░░░░░░░░ 28%
Third-Party Retail:      ████████░░░░░░░░░░░░ 16%
  (grocery, drugstore)
Corporate/B2B:           ██████░░░░░░░░░░░░░░ 11%
Third-Party Digital:     ██░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░  3%

Third-Party Retail Performance: Grocery and drugstore gift card racks remain important for impulse gift purchases. Macy's maintains premium rack positioning alongside luxury brands.

Corporate Channel Growth: B2B gift card sales grew 18% YoY as corporations value Macy's versatility for employee rewards, client gifts, and incentive programs.

---

DISPATCH ADVISORY: Challenges and Opportunities

Current Challenges:

Store Footprint Reduction: Planned store closures reduce redemption convenience for some cardholders. Digital channels must compensate for physical presence gaps.

Generational Perception: Younger consumers may view department stores as parents' or grandparents' retailers. Gift card desirability may decline without brand repositioning.

Amazon Competition: For "practical" gift occasions, Amazon gift cards increasingly win consideration. Macy's must emphasize emotional and experiential differentiators.

Emerging Opportunities:

Wedding Registry Integration: Deeper connection between Macy's registry program and gift cards could capture bridal market share.

Home Goods Expansion: Furniture, bedding, and home décor categories represent growth opportunity as millennials establish households.

Digital Beauty Innovation: Virtual try-on and beauty consultation services could revitalize gift card interest among younger demographics.

---

DISPATCH FORECAST

Short-term (2025): Stable performance expected with modest revenue pressure. Digital acceleration continues. Star Rewards integration deepens gift card engagement.

Medium-term (2026-2027): Strategic store closures complete, creating leaner but more profitable footprint. Gift card program must drive online conversion to compensate.

Long-term Outlook: Macy's gift card relevance depends on brand's broader transformation success. If Macy's establishes clear differentiation from Amazon and specialty retailers, gift cards remain valuable. Without differentiation, slow decline likely.

---

DISPATCH CONCLUSION

Macy's gift cards embody American retail heritage—representing department store shopping traditions spanning generations. The program demonstrates resilience amid challenging retail conditions, adapting through digital innovation and loyalty integration.

The fundamental value proposition—one card unlocking diverse shopping possibilities across fashion, beauty, and home—remains compelling for gift-givers seeking versatility. Macy's must maintain this breadth advantage while modernizing brand perception for future relevance.

---

Department Store Dispatch is an independent retail analysis publication. Content reflects publicly available information and industry research.

Next Dispatch: JCPenney and Kohl's Comparative Gift Card Analysis