I Used to Think Gift Cards Were Lazy Gifts. I Was Wrong.

A confession from someone who learned the hard way

---

Let me be honest with you: three years ago, receiving a gift card felt like an insult. It screamed, "I didn't care enough to find you something real." I would smile politely, tuck the card into my wallet, and secretly feel disappointed.

Then something changed.

The Sweater That Changed Everything

It was my 28th birthday. My sister—who knows me better than almost anyone—gave me a hand-knitted sweater in a shade of orange I can only describe as "aggressive pumpkin." She had spent weeks making it. The love was undeniable.

But here's the truth I couldn't say out loud: I never wore it. Not once.

It sits in my closet to this day, a monument to good intentions and mismatched taste.

That same birthday, my coworker—someone I barely knew outside of meetings—handed me a $25 coffee shop gift card with a simple note: "For your morning sanity."

Guess which gift I used more?

The Real Meaning of "Thoughtful"

We've been conditioned to believe that thoughtful gifting means spending hours finding the perfect item, something that proves we really know the recipient. But here's what I've realized:

True thoughtfulness isn't about what YOU think someone should have. It's about giving them the freedom to choose what they actually want.

When I give you a gift card, I'm not saying "I don't know you." I'm saying:

• I trust your judgment
• I respect your taste
• I want you to have something you'll genuinely use
• I'm not arrogant enough to assume I know better than you

That's not lazy. That's humble.

The Numbers Don't Lie

Since changing my perspective, I've started paying attention to gift-giving patterns among my friends and family:

The carefully selected gifts? About 30% get returned, regifted, or forgotten in closets.

The gift cards? Nearly 100% get used—and people actually remember using them.

My friend Marcus still talks about the restaurant gift card I gave him two years ago. "Best anniversary dinner ever," he told me. I didn't pick the restaurant, the wine, or the meal. I just made it possible.

When Critics Call It "Impersonal"

The main argument against gift cards is that they're impersonal. But let me flip that around:

Is it personal to give someone something they don't want?

Is it personal to make someone feel guilty about not using a gift?

Is it personal to prioritize your own satisfaction as a gift-giver over their happiness as a recipient?

The most personal gift I ever received was a streaming service gift card from my dad. He'd noticed I kept mentioning shows I wanted to watch but hadn't signed up for the service. He paid attention. He listened. And then he gave me the freedom to watch whatever I wanted, whenever I wanted.

That's not impersonal. That's intimacy disguised as plastic.

The Art of the Gift Card

Here's what I've learned about giving gift cards well:

Choose the right card. A generic Visa gift card is fine, but a card to their favorite bookstore, coffee shop, or hobby store shows you pay attention.

Add a note. "For your next adventure" hits different than no note at all. Three seconds of effort transforms the experience.

Don't apologize for it. The moment you say "I know it's not much, but..." you've undermined the gift. Give it confidently.

Consider the amount. Too little feels like an afterthought. Too much feels uncomfortable. Find the sweet spot for your relationship.

My Gift Card Moment

Last Christmas, I gave everyone gift cards. My mom got one for her favorite garden center. My nephew got one for video games. My best friend got one for the spa.

I braced myself for judgment.

Instead, I got texts throughout January:

"Just used your card to buy the most beautiful orchid!"

"THANK YOU! Got the game I've been wanting forever!"

"Spa day was INCREDIBLE. Already booked my next one."

Nobody remembered the physical gifts I'd given previous years. Everyone remembered these.

The Deeper Truth

Here's what giving gift cards has taught me about generosity:

Real giving isn't about proving something about yourself. It's not about showing how creative, thoughtful, or wealthy you are. Real giving is about making someone else's life a little bit better.

Sometimes that means a handmade gift that fits perfectly.

And sometimes—often—it means a small rectangle of plastic that says: "Go ahead. Treat yourself. You deserve it."

---

I was wrong about gift cards. I'm glad I learned. Now, whenever someone gives me one, I don't feel disappointed anymore. I feel understood.

And that, I've discovered, is the greatest gift of all.