7 Questions Everyone Asks About Selling Gift Cards (Answered Honestly)

You've got questions. We've got answers. No jargon, no sales pitch—just the truth about selling gift cards online.

---

Q1: "Is selling my gift card even legal?"

Short answer: Yes, absolutely.

Longer answer: Gift cards are your property. Once someone gives you a gift card, it belongs to you completely. You can use it, regift it, or sell it—just like any other item you own.

The confusion comes from the fact that gift card fraud is illegal (using stolen cards, for example). But selling a legitimate gift card you received as a gift? Perfectly legal. The secondary gift card market processes billions of dollars in transactions annually, and major financial institutions back these platforms.

One caveat: some store terms of service technically prohibit resale, but this is rarely enforced and doesn't make the act illegal—it just means the store could theoretically cancel the card (which almost never happens with legitimate transactions).

---

Q2: "Why can't I get 100% of my card's value?"

Short answer: Because the buyer needs a reason to buy from you instead of the store.

Longer answer: Think about it from the buyer's perspective. If they could buy a $100 gift card from you for $100, why wouldn't they just buy directly from the retailer and earn credit card points?

The discount is the entire value proposition of the secondary market. Buyers get cards below face value; sellers convert unwanted cards to cash. The platform takes a small cut for facilitating the secure transaction.

Typical rates range from 70-92% depending on the retailer's popularity. High-demand cards (major retailers, restaurants, entertainment) fetch higher prices. Niche or regional stores typically offer lower rates.

---

Q3: "What's stopping someone from using my card after I sell it?"

Short answer: Technology and timing.

Longer answer: Legitimate platforms have systems to prevent this:

First, verification happens fast. The moment you enter your card details, the system checks the balance in real-time. If the balance doesn't match what you claimed, the transaction stops.

Second, once verified, most platforms either immediately transfer the card to a secure holding account or process payment so quickly that there's no window for misuse.

Third, reputable platforms offer seller protection. If something goes wrong during a legitimate transaction, you're covered.

The risk isn't zero, but on established platforms, it's extremely low—comparable to selling anything else online through a major marketplace.

---

Q4: "How do I know if a platform is legitimate?"

Short answer: Look for three things: history, reviews, and payment methods.

Longer answer:

History matters. How long has the platform operated? Scam sites tend to disappear quickly. Platforms that have been around for years and process millions in transactions have reputations to protect.

Reviews tell stories. Check independent review sites, not just testimonials on the platform itself. Look for patterns in complaints. One-off issues happen everywhere; systematic problems are red flags.

Payment methods reveal legitimacy. Legitimate platforms offer standard payment options: bank transfers, PayPal, direct deposit. If a site only accepts cryptocurrency or asks for unusual payment arrangements, walk away.

Also trust your instincts. If rates seem impossibly good or the site feels unprofessional, it probably is.

---

Q5: "Should I sell locally or online?"

Short answer: Online, unless you personally know the buyer.

Longer answer:

Selling to strangers locally (Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace) carries real risks. You hand over the card; they "check" it on their phone; they claim it's empty or invalid. Now what? You have no protection, no proof, and no recourse.

Online platforms provide:

• Verified balances before transactions complete
• Secure payment processing
• Dispute resolution systems
• Transaction records

The slight reduction in payout compared to a private sale is essentially the cost of security and convenience. For most people, it's worth it.

Exception: selling to someone you personally know and trust is fine. Just don't meet strangers in parking lots to exchange gift cards for cash.

---

Q6: "How long does it take to get paid?"

Short answer: Usually 1-3 business days, sometimes faster.

Longer answer: It depends on:

The platform: Some offer instant payment options (usually at slightly lower rates). Standard processing typically takes 1-3 business days.

Your payment method: Direct bank transfers are often fastest. PayPal is quick. Checks (if offered) are slowest.

Verification requirements: First-time sellers sometimes face additional verification steps—proving identity, confirming bank accounts. This is annoying but protects everyone from fraud.

The card itself: Some cards require extra verification steps if they've been flagged for unusual activity or come from certain sources.

If a platform promises instant payment with no verification on your first transaction, be suspicious. Legitimate platforms balance speed with security.

---

Q7: "What happens to my card after I sell it?"

Short answer: Someone buys it at a discount and uses it.

Longer answer: Your card enters a marketplace where buyers browse for discounts on stores they actually shop at. Someone purchasing groceries anyway might grab your grocery card at 8% off. A gamer might snag your gaming card for a discount on their next purchase.

The buyer uses the card; the retailer gets their sale; you got cash for something you wouldn't have used. Everyone benefits.

Some cards get resold to other platforms or bulk buyers. Some go to businesses that use them for employee rewards or customer incentives. The secondary market is larger and more sophisticated than most people realize.

Your card's journey continues—it just continues with someone who actually wants it.

---

The Bottom Line

Selling gift cards isn't complicated, but it does require choosing the right platform and understanding what you're getting into. The key points:

• It's legal and common
• You won't get full value (and shouldn't expect to)
• Legitimate platforms protect both buyers and sellers
• Online sales are generally safer than local exchanges
• Payment typically takes a few days

Got more questions? The gift card economy might seem mysterious, but it's really just matching people who have cards with people who want them—with technology making the whole process safer and more efficient than ever before.